Home

The Economic Populist

Speak Your Mind 2 Cents at a Time

Discussion

  • Forums
    • Labor Economics
      • Labor
      • Outsourcing/Insourcing
        • Immigration
        • Professional Labor Issues
    • Macro Economics
      • Fiscal, Monetary Policy
      • Global
      • Tax Policy
      • Trade Policy
      • Wall Street
    • Politics
      • Congress
      • Executive Branch
    • Admin
  • Home
  • Reads
  • Discuss
  • RSS Feed
  • Twitter
  • About
  • Contact
Home Blogs New Deal democrat's blog

New blog posts

  • A Brief History of Securitization
  • Cuomo Takes on The Money Party
  • PIGS and the ouzo effect
  • Sunday Morning Comics - Yeah Yes Men Edition
  • Must Read Posts - Sometimes you just can't say it better for 02.06.10
  • Friday Movie Night - 25 Million Pounds
  • Is Residential Real Estate a Ticking Time Bomb?
  • It's time to live within our means once again
  • U.S. Manufacturing, Hire America & Buy American
  • Sunday Morning Comics - Hayek vs. Keynes Edition
more

User login

  • Create new account
  • Request new password

Navigation

  • User Guide
  • News aggregator

Recent Comments

  • Hi I am from Slovakia - a
    4 hours 7 min ago
  • Oh yes
    7 hours 1 min ago
  • Dylan Ratigan show today
    7 hours 38 min ago
  • SIGTARP is "the tell"
    9 hours 34 min ago
  • Actually,
    9 hours 44 min ago
  • What surprised me about that interview
    9 hours 49 min ago
  • True, but they are only making matters....
    11 hours 22 min ago
  • Part of the problem is the dire straits of states and cities
    12 hours 9 min ago
  • automatic graph scaling
    14 hours 30 min ago
  • Thanks
    15 hours 14 min ago
  • Euro being heavily shorted now
    15 hours 34 min ago
  • blog post idea
    15 hours 45 min ago
  • Great Post
    15 hours 52 min ago
  • there goes what's left of savings and retirement funds
    16 hours 56 min ago
  • FYI
    17 hours 3 min ago
  • Let's sure hope so
    18 hours 56 min ago
  • Greece default doesn't matter yet then it does ...
    20 hours 30 min ago
  • Actually the biggest waste of government money
    20 hours 46 min ago
  • We're In Holding Pattern Until 2012..
    23 hours 29 min ago
  • When is the MSM going to point out we are LOSING the best jobs?
    1 day 22 min ago

Poll

Populist Du Jour

  • Holy Cow Batman! SIGTARP Barofsky says U.S. on the hook for $23.7 Trillion in bail out!

Vox Populi

  • Holy Cow Batman! SIGTARP Barofsky says U.S. on the hook for $23.7 Trillion in bail out!
  • Subprime meltdown over; now comes the bad news
  • The Deflationary Recession of 2009?
  • The Panic of 2008: a turning point
  • Text of Bail Out Act Before Congress - TAKE ACTION NOW!
  • Scientist Who Laid Ground Work for Nobel Prize Drives a Bus, Can't get a Job
  • 2009: Recession vs. Recovery (Update 4)

Active forum topics

  • How important is Greece?
  • Economic Stress hits new record
more

Atlanta Fed's Macroblog

  • Is good news hidden in bad employment numbers?
  • Southeast businesses offer insights on capital spending plans
more

iMFdirect

  • Getting Ready to Join the Eurozone Club
  • More to Do on Financial Sector Tax, Says IMF’s Lipsky
more

CBO

  • CBO Estimates a Federal Budget Deficit of $434 Billion in the First Four Months of Fiscal Year 2010
  • How Reducing Payroll Taxes Can Encourage Employment
more

powells

GAO

  • GAO-10-248, Highway Research: The Second Strategic Highway Research Program Addresses the Four Required Areas, but Some Anticipated Research Was Not Funded, February 5, 2010
  • GAO-10-25, Troubled Asset Relief Program: Treasury Needs to Strengthen Its Decision-Making Process on the Term Asset-Backed Securities Loan Facility, February 5, 2010
more

Instapopulist

  • Economic Stress hits new record
  • The Federal Reserve's Exit Plan is Another Bank Bail Out Pig Fest
  • How important is Greece?
  • China Eastern Jiangsu Provence raises minimum wage, wow $140 a month!
  • Bank Failure Friday - one this week, 200 failures expected this year
  • Dr. Robert Reich on financial reform
  • Banksters ready to side-step new credit card rules
more

Calculated Risk

  • D.C. Closed Again on Tuesday and Euro Perspective
  • Greek Finance Minister: Call for help "worst possible signal"
more

Naked Capitalism

  • Links 2/9/10
  • Head of BIS Calls for Bigger Liquidity Buffers
more

Paul Krugman

  • Euro perspective
  • Know Your Deficits
more

dorgan

The Baseline Scenario

  • Elizabeth Warren Calls Out Wall Street
  • Whose Fault?
more

EPI

  • Unemployment drops to 9.7% despite more job losses
  • Unemployment rate drops to 9.7% despite more job losses
more

Eyes on Trade

  • Exciteable Young Men
  • Exciteable Young Men
more

Econbrowser

  • Letting the EGTRRA and JGTRRA Provisions Expire
  • Reactions to last week's economic data
more

TradeReform.org

  • Much Of China's 2009 Steel Made Without Proper Permits -Report
  • Biggest Bubble in History Is Growing Every Day
more

EconomPic

  • Market Recap (2/08/10)
  • Women Taking Over the Workforce
more

Economist's View

  • "Fine Print, Deceptive Pricing, and Buried Tricks"
  • "The Inexact Science of Economics"
more

Economy in Crisis

  • Why Layoffs are Not Beneficial to Companies
  • A Growing Concern
more

The Big Picture

  • The Crumbling Greek Economy
  • Corporate credit markets feeling the correction too
more

Credit Slips

  • Bankruptcies Maintain Similar Month-to-Month Rate in January
  • Monetary Policy and the Housing Bubble
more

Manufacture This

  • The Future of Manufacturing…Part Five
  • Dr. Peter Morici Says the U.S. Economy is in “Shambles”
more

Alan Tonelson

  • More on Obama's Export Delusions
  • Domestic Manufacturers Urge Obama to Back Up Tougher China Talk With Immediate Currency-Manipulation Bill Push
more

black swan

Beat The Press

  • Jingoism and the Budget Deficit: Using Any Tactic to Advance the Budget Cutting Agenda
  • Social Security Benefits Will Be Paid, It is the Law
more

Nouriel Roubini's Global EconoMonitor

  • Roubini Bloomberg Interview on Sovereign Debt and U.S. Outlook
  • RGE's Weekly Roundup
more

Zero Hedge

  • The Coming Pan-European Soverign Debt Crisis
  • Why Casinos Deserve Our Trust More Than Banks
more

The Mess That Greenspan Made

  • The new Canadian housing bubble?
  • An interview with Fred Sheehan
more

Tax Justice Network

  • Football premier league seeks elite opt-out
  • Switzerland must consider automatic information exchange - finance minister
more

Brad Delong

  • links for 2010-02-09
  • Pretending that Nothing Is Wrong When Your Hair on Fire Does Not Send a Good Signal...
more

Steve Keen's Debtwatch

  • Interview on Switzer TV
  • Vote for Ignoble/Dynamite Economics Prize
more

New Deal 2.0

  • Bill Black to BofA Chairman: Racist bank adviser in Germany must go
  • Straws in the Wind: The 5 Supremes
more

Pension Pulse

  • Drop in Dividends Leaves Pensions Exposed?
  • Another Freaky Friday?
more

Angry Bear

  • AN IMMODEST PROPOSAL
  • In Other News, Larry King is Selling Divorce Insurance
more

Robert Reich

  • 2010 Rancho Mirage Speakers Series
  • Who's Killing Financial Reform?
more

Noslaves.com

  • Economy in Crisis Calls Out Bill Gates and Lobbyist H-1B Propaganda
  • Jobs Bill
more

Financial Armageddon

  • The Next Phase of My Evaluation
  • The Next Phase of My Evaluation
more

The Fannie/Freddie "Conservatorship": Sometimes abject despair is appropriate

Submitted by New Deal democrat on Sat, 09/06/2008 - 06:11.
  • bailout
  • conservatorship
  • Fannie
  • Freddie
  • Shock Doctrine

I've been asked what my thoughts are about the Fannie and Freddie bailout leaked by the Treasury to the NYTimes and the Washington Post late Friday afternoon.
Since the actual details haven't been released, and you can click over to Tanta and Barry Ritholtz as easily as I can, I suggest you go there for the best exposition so far of the proposed details. In fact, Ritholtz' "The Big Picture" has a pretty good multi-point presentation, which forms the basis for my comments below.
This story is MAJOR, in multiple ways, and almost none of it good, particularly for the long-term. Some points below.

1. The bailout seems to boil down to (1) the government explicitly takes over the mortgage giants (2) largely wipes out their shareholders (3) injects perhaps $500 BILLION into them, and (4) guarantees their debts.

2. The biggie by far is the guarantee of $5 TRILLION of mortgages. You and me, fellow taxpayer, are on the hook. It doesn't matter if we're renters, or are fiscally prudent, never took out a HELOC, never leveraged up to the hilt: too effing bad for you, you are guaranteeing the debt of the people who did. The only good thing here is that Fannie and Freddie were relatively prudent during the housing bubble, and so perhaps only 5% to 10% of their debt may blow up. But that's still $100s of billions you and me and our descendants directly pay out.

3. So much for the government only injecting a few $10s of billions. Only a month after receiving a blank check from Congress, it is being cashed for the first time at perhaps 10x the promised amount!

4. Fannie and Freddie are now under the direct political control of the Unitary Executive Bush Administration. They can reorganize them however they wish. You may wish to brush up on how the Bush Administration has handled Iraq and Katrina, and recognize that this Bustout is maybe 10x as large as both of them combined, to have an idea how that will play out.

5. The aforesaid blank check was handed to the Bush Administration after about 2 days of foreplay (not investigation, not oversight) by a DEMOCRATIC House of Representatives and a DEMOCRATIC Senate. These people, collectively, have shown not the slightest interest in actually protecting average Americans (most of whom were not caught up in the housing bubble), or ensuring even the slightest bit of oversight. Both political parties are in hock to the plutocrats, the middle and working classes are friendless.

6. Our new Chinese creditors have demanded their first payment. Several times in the last week, Chinese officials have stated in no unceertain terms that they would be VERY UNHAPPY if their Fannie and Freddie bonds weren't honored in full. Forget the Fed: US economic conditions are now dictated by the People's Bank of China.

7. This is what happens to debtor countries. Read my prior dairies explaining the book "Bankruptcy 1995." This is only a harbinger of national debt peonage to come.

8. Disaster Capitalism and "The Shock Doctrine" have come to Wall Street. Readers of Naomi Klein's book recall the thesis that Chicago School type right-wing privatizations happen during real or conjured economic emergencies, and are usually enacted by executive fiat. With the exception of New Orleans and Katrina, until now the recipients of those "shocks" have been third world nations. With this crony capitalist bailout, for the first time Main Street America is the recipient of the Shock Doctrine treatment, treating average Americans exactly as American plutocratic overlords treated Argentinians, Brazilians, South Africans, Russians, Poles, Peruvians, and countless others in the last several decades. You should expect much more of this in the next several years. (Just wait until the World Bank and the IMF demand the dismantling of Social Security and Medicare in order to approve a bridge loan to the US government).

9. It is good to be Bill Gross. Bill Gross of PIMCO has been nakedly "talking his book" for the last couple of months, insisting that the Feds must bail out Fannie and Freddie. Yesterday on CNBC he explicitly said he was unable to comment on this bailout (meaning he had inside knowledge). It must be nice to get Uncle Sam to bail out bad investment decisions. You and I can't do that.

10. Libertarians are Stupid. They always trumpet free market capitalism on the way up, but they never see the bailout for billionaires coming when the sh*t hits the fan, do they? And the bailout ALWAYS comes.

I'm sure there is more, and I'll comment more once the actual terms of the bailout are released (although I suspect even then there will be escape clauses allowing for Treasury secrecy). In the meantime, drowning your intellect with the intoxicating beverage of your choice is not a bad thing. Sometimes abject despair is the appropriate reaction.

UPDATE: Another important consideration is to ask, exactly why did this happen? The chronology, and who benefits, is important. What really happened will turn your stomach when the truth is exposed in a few years, imho.

Ask yourself this: what has happened to Fannie and Freddie materially since July?

Answer: Nothing. They are in basically the same shape. And the stock market isn't imploding since then either. It is basically where is was 2-3 months ago.

So, why the "bailout" now?

Ask yourself, "who benefits?"

And there is your answer.

At the end of June, there were wild rumors - in the European, not US press (how convenient?) - about the US financial system imploding in a couple of weeks (MidtownG wrote a very interesting diary describing those rumors if you recall).

In July, based largely on those rumors, the stock market declined significantly. Then, out of the blue and for no particular reason, a Wall Street I-bank, using accounting that everyone agrees is not apposite, called Fannie and Freddie insolvent.
The very next day, a former Fed official, now with the Cato Institute, and a long term opponent of Fannie and Freddie, chimed in and agreed Fannie and Freddie were on the verge of insolvency.

Short interest in Fannie and Freddie exploded (much of this was most likely illegal "naked" shorting). Fannie and Freddie's value collapsed in a couple of days.

Within the week, the Bush Administration went to Congress and asked for a blank check. Congress obliged. For those of you who read it, you should be strongly reminded of other incidents described by Naomi Klein in "The Shock Doctrine."

As soon as the "crisis" passed, suddenly the Bush Administration was interested in preventing "naked" shorting. BTW, "bear raids" which are shorting a stock and spreading rumors of e.g. insolvency are crimes.

Authority in hand, the Bush Administration has now taken complete control of Fannie and Freddie.

That, in my opinion, is what really happened here.

  • New Deal democrat's blog
  • addthis
  • Email this Blog entry
  • 1 point

I had an interesting coversation at the

Submitted by manfrommiddletown on Sat, 09/06/2008 - 08:03.

bank yesterday.

Every time I move and go in to my new local Chase branch, they always try to get me to sit down with a personal banker. Who then tries to talk me into some kind of investment situation with Chase. I always explain that I'm not interested.

Yesterday, they try to talk me into a CD, and I tell them that their rates aren't good enough for me. So I tell this personal banker that if I was really interested in a CD, I'd go to WaMu because they've got much better rates.

So she says something that surprised me. She says to me that if they're offering that kind of deal you ought to be worried about how solid the bank is, and how an article would be coming out soon saying how Chase was. I wonder if we aren't on the brink of a large number of bank failures,

Not yet rated.
  • reply

Implode-O-Meter

Submitted by Robert Oak on Sat, 09/06/2008 - 11:55.

This site does a watch list on failing banks. Only a blog can make it fun to watch financial institutions collapse.

Not yet rated.
  • reply

Who Benefits?

Submitted by Robert Oak on Sat, 09/06/2008 - 10:07.

China, Japan and others reduced holdings in GSEs earlier this month, but seemingly still have large holdings. Does this leave them with worthless stock or does it help them?

From Bloomberg:

The meetings come a month after Paulson hired Morgan Stanley to advise on any use of taxpayer funds to recapitalize Fannie and Freddie, which account for almost half of the $12 trillion mortgage market

WaPo is reporting that preferred shares will be protected while common stock will be diluted.

hmmm....now who usually owns preferred stock?

Not yet rated.
  • reply

some $$ numbers popping up

Submitted by Robert Oak on Sun, 09/07/2008 - 16:55.

CNN Money is saying it will cost an initial $200B.

Not yet rated.
  • reply

Bonddad on Huffington Post

Submitted by Robert Oak on Sun, 09/07/2008 - 19:05.

has even more details.

He's mentioning the foreign investors, China specifically and how there is no way they are going to allow their investments to go to zero.

Good read. (He's also citing you New Deal).

Not yet rated.
  • reply

little for homeowners

Submitted by Robert Oak on Sun, 09/07/2008 - 20:27.

more details:

But for homeowners already behind on their mortgage payments, or who owe more than their homes are now worth, the plan unveiled Sunday by Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson offers little in the way of extra relief

Not yet rated.
  • reply

Paulson dumping it on Next Pres

Submitted by Robert Oak on Sun, 09/07/2008 - 23:38.

This is priceless, according to Bloomberg the entire seize is simply a stop gap measure and they are going to dump the mortgage crisis on the next administration.

So glad they are going to clean up their own mess.

Not yet rated.
  • reply

credit default swaps "setttled"

Submitted by Robert Oak on Mon, 09/08/2008 - 09:20.

No more placing bets on Fannie and Freddie debt? - Bloomberg is reporting they will settle credit default swaps.

Not yet rated.
  • reply

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Input format
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <b> <address> <blockquote> <br> <caption> <center> <code> <dd> <del> <div> <dl> <dt> <em> <font> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <hr> <i> <img> <li> <ol> <p> <pre> <span> <strong> <sub> <sup> <table> <tbody> <td> <tfoot> <th> <thead> <tr> <u> <ul> <tr>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Image links with 'rel="lightbox"' in the <a> tag will appear in a Lightbox when clicked on.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.

Syndicate

Syndicate content

Add to Technorati Favorites

Privacy Policy

Google Delicious Yahoo! Bloglines Newsgator MSN AOL Rojo Newsburst RSSFwd
© Economic Populist 2008-2009