Home

The Economic Populist

Speak Your Mind 2 Cents at a Time

Discussion

  • Forums
    • Labor Economics
      • Labor
      • Outsourcing/Insourcing
        • Immigration
        • Professional Labor Issues
    • Macro Economics
      • Fiscal, Monetary Policy
      • Global
      • Tax Policy
      • Trade Policy
      • Wall Street
    • Politics
      • Congress
      • Executive Branch
    • Admin
  • Home
  • Reads
  • Discuss
  • RSS Feed
  • Twitter
  • About
  • Contact
Home Blogs Robert Oak's blog

New blog posts

  • A Brief History of Securitization
  • Cuomo Takes on The Money Party
  • PIGS and the ouzo effect
  • Sunday Morning Comics - Yeah Yes Men Edition
  • Must Read Posts - Sometimes you just can't say it better for 02.06.10
  • Friday Movie Night - 25 Million Pounds
  • Is Residential Real Estate a Ticking Time Bomb?
  • It's time to live within our means once again
  • U.S. Manufacturing, Hire America & Buy American
  • Sunday Morning Comics - Hayek vs. Keynes Edition
more

User login

  • Create new account
  • Request new password

Navigation

  • User Guide
  • News aggregator

Recent Comments

  • Hi I am from Slovakia - a
    8 hours 10 min ago
  • Oh yes
    11 hours 4 min ago
  • Dylan Ratigan show today
    11 hours 41 min ago
  • SIGTARP is "the tell"
    13 hours 37 min ago
  • Actually,
    13 hours 47 min ago
  • What surprised me about that interview
    13 hours 52 min ago
  • True, but they are only making matters....
    15 hours 25 min ago
  • Part of the problem is the dire straits of states and cities
    16 hours 12 min ago
  • automatic graph scaling
    18 hours 33 min ago
  • Thanks
    19 hours 17 min ago
  • Euro being heavily shorted now
    19 hours 37 min ago
  • blog post idea
    19 hours 48 min ago
  • Great Post
    19 hours 55 min ago
  • there goes what's left of savings and retirement funds
    20 hours 59 min ago
  • FYI
    21 hours 6 min ago
  • Let's sure hope so
    22 hours 59 min ago
  • Greece default doesn't matter yet then it does ...
    1 day 33 min ago
  • Actually the biggest waste of government money
    1 day 49 min ago
  • We're In Holding Pattern Until 2012..
    1 day 3 hours ago
  • When is the MSM going to point out we are LOSING the best jobs?
    1 day 4 hours ago

Poll

Populist Du Jour

  • Holy Cow Batman! SIGTARP Barofsky says U.S. on the hook for $23.7 Trillion in bail out!

Vox Populi

  • Holy Cow Batman! SIGTARP Barofsky says U.S. on the hook for $23.7 Trillion in bail out!
  • Subprime meltdown over; now comes the bad news
  • The Deflationary Recession of 2009?
  • The Panic of 2008: a turning point
  • Text of Bail Out Act Before Congress - TAKE ACTION NOW!
  • Scientist Who Laid Ground Work for Nobel Prize Drives a Bus, Can't get a Job
  • 2009: Recession vs. Recovery (Update 4)

Active forum topics

  • How important is Greece?
  • Economic Stress hits new record
more

Atlanta Fed's Macroblog

  • Is good news hidden in bad employment numbers?
  • Southeast businesses offer insights on capital spending plans
more

iMFdirect

  • Getting Ready to Join the Eurozone Club
  • More to Do on Financial Sector Tax, Says IMF’s Lipsky
more

CBO

  • Visit to Morehouse College
  • CBO Estimates a Federal Budget Deficit of $434 Billion in the First Four Months of Fiscal Year 2010
more

powells

GAO

  • GAO-10-248, Highway Research: The Second Strategic Highway Research Program Addresses the Four Required Areas, but Some Anticipated Research Was Not Funded, February 5, 2010
  • GAO-10-25, Troubled Asset Relief Program: Treasury Needs to Strengthen Its Decision-Making Process on the Term Asset-Backed Securities Loan Facility, February 5, 2010
more

Instapopulist

  • Economic Stress hits new record
  • The Federal Reserve's Exit Plan is Another Bank Bail Out Pig Fest
  • How important is Greece?
  • China Eastern Jiangsu Provence raises minimum wage, wow $140 a month!
  • Bank Failure Friday - one this week, 200 failures expected this year
  • Dr. Robert Reich on financial reform
  • Banksters ready to side-step new credit card rules
more

Calculated Risk

  • NFIB: Small Business Owners Report "shortage of customers"
  • D.C. Closed Again on Tuesday and Euro Perspective
more

Naked Capitalism

  • Links 2/9/10
  • Head of BIS Calls for Bigger Liquidity Buffers
more

Paul Krugman

  • Euro perspective
  • Know Your Deficits
more

dorgan

The Baseline Scenario

  • Elizabeth Warren Calls Out Wall Street
  • Whose Fault?
more

EPI

  • Unemployment drops to 9.7% despite more job losses
  • Unemployment rate drops to 9.7% despite more job losses
more

Eyes on Trade

  • Exciteable Young Men
  • Exciteable Young Men
more

Econbrowser

  • Letting the EGTRRA and JGTRRA Provisions Expire
  • Reactions to last week's economic data
more

TradeReform.org

  • Much Of China's 2009 Steel Made Without Proper Permits -Report
  • Biggest Bubble in History Is Growing Every Day
more

EconomPic

  • The Death of the Workforce
  • Market Recap (2/08/10)
more

Economist's View

  • "Fine Print, Deceptive Pricing, and Buried Tricks"
  • "The Inexact Science of Economics"
more

Economy in Crisis

  • Why Layoffs are Not Beneficial to Companies
  • A Growing Concern
more

The Big Picture

  • 5 Most Expensive Pieces of Art
  • Food Stamps – The Great Recession’s Soup Lines
more

Credit Slips

  • Bankruptcies Maintain Similar Month-to-Month Rate in January
  • Monetary Policy and the Housing Bubble
more

Manufacture This

  • The Early Shift
  • The Future of Manufacturing…Part Five
more

Alan Tonelson

  • More on Obama's Export Delusions
  • Domestic Manufacturers Urge Obama to Back Up Tougher China Talk With Immediate Currency-Manipulation Bill Push
more

black swan

Beat The Press

  • Jingoism and the Budget Deficit: Using Any Tactic to Advance the Budget Cutting Agenda
  • Social Security Benefits Will Be Paid, It is the Law
more

Nouriel Roubini's Global EconoMonitor

  • Roubini Bloomberg Interview on Sovereign Debt and U.S. Outlook
  • RGE's Weekly Roundup
more

Zero Hedge

  • S&P Revises Outlooks on Citigroup, Bank Of America To Negative From Stable
  • First Greece, Now Spain: Moore Capital, Brevan Howard, Paulson As Well As JPM And Goldman Implicated In Spanish CDS Rout
more

The Mess That Greenspan Made

  • On the Fed's exit strategy
  • Tuesday morning links
more

Tax Justice Network

  • OECD: involve civil society and developing countries in peer review process
  • Football premier league seeks elite opt-out
more

Brad Delong

  • links for 2010-02-09
  • Pretending that Nothing Is Wrong When Your Hair on Fire Does Not Send a Good Signal...
more

Steve Keen's Debtwatch

  • Interview on Switzer TV
  • Vote for Ignoble/Dynamite Economics Prize
more

New Deal 2.0

  • Bill Black to BofA Chairman: Racist bank adviser in Germany must go
  • Straws in the Wind: The 5 Supremes
more

Pension Pulse

  • Greece Implements Pension Reforms
  • Drop in Dividends Leaves Pensions Exposed?
more

Angry Bear

  • Limit Banks' Proprietary Trading? Links Worth Noting on Possible Reprise of Glass Steagall Maybe
  • AN IMMODEST PROPOSAL
more

Robert Reich

  • Obomanomics One Year Out
  • 2010 Rancho Mirage Speakers Series
more

Noslaves.com

  • Economy in Crisis Calls Out Bill Gates and Lobbyist H-1B Propaganda
  • Jobs Bill
more

Financial Armageddon

  • The Next Phase of My Evaluation
  • The Next Phase of My Evaluation
more

New COP Report - Guarantees Created Significant Moral Hazard

Submitted by Robert Oak on Mon, 11/09/2009 - 20:33.
  • bail out
  • COP
  • Federal Reserve
  • TARP
  • treasury

On Friday you were probably bowled over by the unemployment rate. So astounded, we missed this major report release by COP, the Congressional Oversight Panel on TARP.

The Report, Guarantees and Contingent Payments in TARP and Related Programs is another damning condemnation on corporate socialism to the point of moral hazard. Yet, at the same time, the report says taxpayers will likely profit from the huge TARP gamble. Well, well, if the government is turning the world into a glorified casino with U.S. taxpayer money, all the while guaranteeing the bonuses profits of large banks, at least it looks like we won't take the loss.

The Panel found that the programs' income will likely exceed their direct expenditures, and that guarantees played a major role in calming financial markets. These same programs, however, exposed American taxpayers to trillions of dollars in guarantees and created significant moral hazard that distorts the marketplace.


 

Firstly to the money! So far the program has received $17.4 billion in fees. The OMB has projected profits to be $752 million past the original TARP lending. That said, the OMB is under the Obama administration and... what was that jobs estimate again on Stimulus? hmmmm.....

The report lists these risks of Treasury Funds still for the taxpayer (see report for magic decoder ring on programs):

  • The TGPMMF has ended with no loss, but $3.6 billion was used from the ESF to purchase assets from the USGF outside of the TGPMMF.
  • The DGP currently guarantees a principal amount of $307 billion (plus interest), which will diminish as June 2012 approaches, with $2 million in expected losses to date.
  • The AGP guarantee for Citigroup is still in place, and initial actuarial estimates point towards a possible $34.6 billion loss under the moderate stress test scenario and $43.9
    billion loss under the severe stress test scenario, which, after the 39.5 billion “deductible,” would result in no loss for the government entities under the moderate scenario and a loss of $3.96 billion to Treasury under the severe scenario. The AGP guarantee for Bank of America ended with no loss.

Note the Panel is asking about Citigroup.

Treasury is contractually obligated to continue guaranteeing Citigroup assets until 2013 (for non-residential assets in the guaranteed pool) or 2018 (for residential assets in the guaranteed pool).

While Treasury, the Federal Reserve, and the FDIC provided extensive details of the mechanics with respect to additional assistance to Citigroup and Bank of America, the rationale underlying the guarantees remains somewhat unclear.

To date the three agencies have not disclosed why these programs were selected; why Citigroup and Bank of America were the only institutions selected for asset guarantee protection; what alternatives were available; and why those alternatives were not chosen.

Most interesting is under a moderate Stress Test scenario, Citigroup can lose $34.6 billion. Bear in mind the unemployment rate is much larger than in the original stress tests.

The recommendations are:

  • First, the Panel recommends that Treasury disclose the rationale behind the creation of guarantee programs, including a discussion of any alternatives, why those were not selected, a cost-benefit analysis of all options, and why Citigroup and Bank of America were the only institutions selected for asset guarantee protection.
  • Second, the Panel recommends that Treasury fully and publicly disclose its legal justification for creating the TGPMMF through the use of the Exchange Stabilization Fund. Treasury should also provide reports of the total number of money market funds participating in the program, or the total dollar value guaranteed, for each month that the program was in existence.
  • The Panel also recommends that the MOUs with Citigroup and Bank of America, and the MOU with any other institution relevant to this report on the AGP and other TARP-related guarantees, be provided to the Panel to inform its oversight functions, to be used subject to applicable legal protections.
  • Finally, the Panel recommends that Treasury provide regular disclosures relating to the guarantee of Citigroup assets under the AGP, including the final composition of the asset pool (as reflected on Schedule A to the Master Agreement) and total asset pool losses to date, as well as projected losses of the pool, and how these estimates have been calculated.

Ok, so the U.S. Treasury has crossed a line with corporate socialism for which there may be no return. Citigroup appears to still be a black hole. Yet, so far, U.S. taxpayer money isn't actually going down the drain, although the government put it on the Roulette wheel and spun.

Awesome! Aren't you glad Elizabeth Warren is even there? One statement I appreciate is this:

With so many stabilization initiatives in use at any time, it is impossible to attribute specific results to a particular initiative.

No joke. Did the U.S. government just baffle global finance with a complicated web of financial program confusion, bet the farm, crossed their fingers and hoped it all worked?

The report has numerous tables, so I suggest at least scanning it.

Don't miss Senator Bernie Sander's Too Big To Fail - Too Big To Exist, bill. The legislation plain gives powers to break up systemically risky institutions. (duh!) Believe it or not, Senator Sanders bill is gaining support, of course what 98% of the American people want doesn't usually mean a thing in D.C.

  • Robert Oak's blog
  • addthis
  • Email this Blog entry
  • 1 point

note, the profits are just guarantees

Submitted by Robert Oak on Wed, 11/11/2009 - 14:11.

not the total TARP program. According to the last SIGTARP report, we know $50 billion is assuredly lost from the Home Buy assistance and the report stated the auto loans are probably lost as well.

Not yet rated.
  • reply

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Input format
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <b> <address> <blockquote> <br> <caption> <center> <code> <dd> <del> <div> <dl> <dt> <em> <font> <h2> <h3> <h4> <h5> <h6> <hr> <i> <img> <li> <ol> <p> <pre> <span> <strong> <sub> <sup> <table> <tbody> <td> <tfoot> <th> <thead> <tr> <u> <ul> <tr>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Image links with 'rel="lightbox"' in the <a> tag will appear in a Lightbox when clicked on.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.

Syndicate

Syndicate content

Add to Technorati Favorites

Privacy Policy

Google Delicious Yahoo! Bloglines Newsgator MSN AOL Rojo Newsburst RSSFwd
© Economic Populist 2008-2009